MyBlogLog or BlogCatalog?

Anyone that surfs the internet can help but notice that blogs are all the rage right now. It seems that EVERYONE has a blog, from stay at home moms to corporate moguls (including this site!). As the number of blogs has increased, so have the number of sites for blog owners and readers. There are tons of social networking sites for blog owners, but not all will make the cut. Aside from the granddaddy of them all Technorati, there are two definite networking camps: MyBlogLog and BlogCatalog.

If you’ve visited a blog lately, odds are that the blog has one (or possibly both) of the recent visitor widgets installed. So it begs the question, which site is better? Personally, I prefer having a mybloglog profile to one on blogcatalog. Looking at the sites themselves, mybloglog seems to have more pages indexed by around 50,000 than my blogcatalog. The main reason I like mybloglog is that they give you a profile without asking anything from you in return. You can upgrade your blog with a few stat programs, viewable through your profile or add the recent viewer’s widget to your site as well. Blogcatalog requires that you link back to the site before you can join the community.

The stated main goal of both sites is to let you connect to other bloggers and increase your readership. I have to say that mybloglog does that very well. It automatically adds you to communities (blogs) that you visit often, tracks your visitors and allows other readers to see what’s popular in the communities you belong to as well. As for blogcatalog, I can’t say as I’m not a member.

If you rely on word of mouth to gain readership, than belonging to both sites may be just the thing to help you increase readership. Now, if I only get Max to be more social!

About the author: Charles Richey is the webmaster for lvrealty.net, a Las Vegas real estate site.

One of the reasons BlogCatalog has less pages is that each blog in blogcatalog is approved by an actual person to assure that the blog has at least a couple of posts and that the blog is not just one big advertisement. Only about 1 out of every 3 or 4 blogs are approved from the hundreds of daily submissions. The idea is to create a community of blogs by people who are actually interested in blogging and to cut down on the amount of spam found in larger communities.
Photo of Max Chirkov.
Charles, I never was a social person :) I wish I was though :) Thanks for the post!
Would like to know if your opinion about social communities being a fad or a long-term source of socialization? Nine's post is rather interesting that BlogCatalog is more selective through an approval process. What I would like to know, because BlogCatalog is more selective will it actually carry more trust than mybloglog due to it being selective?
I prefer mybloglog, it is more user friendly for blogs with their widgets. but in probably all reality it there is probably no difference, unless one gets more PR than the other.
There are clear differences between the 2 social networks. Visit the home pages and you will clearly notice a difference on focus. MyBlogLog's shome page seems to be more focused on bloggers adding their widget to their blogs than anything else. There home page displays, a link to 2 bloggers' communities and then a large advertisement for their widget. Visit BlogCatalog's home page and the focus is on the Community of Bloggers and their blogs.
I prefer mybloglog too. Mybloglog receives a lots of visitors and is growing day by day.
I just noticed something with BlogCatalog- The RSS feed has Nofollow. They also use Javscript Onclick. JavaScript onclick does not pass PageRank either. Matt Cutts from Google has commented in the past that these sort of links won’t pass PageRank because of the “onclick” behavior in the JavaScript.
Photo of Max Chirkov.
So there isn't an SEO benefit with BlogCatalog. But they gain one when you install their widget, which is mandatory.
MyBlogLog is better in my opinion largely because it is owned and backed by Yahoo! which means it has the funding and means to thrive in this market.
I've never seen widgets mandatory with MyBlogLog.